WESLEY AKUM-OJONG (U6) The contrast between what constitutes a good person and a good citizen is one that has been debated since ancient times, with Aristotle holding ‘the excellence of a citizen must be an excellence relative to the constitution’, while the good person ‘is a man so called in virtue of a single absolute excellence’. Often what is legal - what a good citizen should follow - and what is considered moral - what a good person should follow - deviate to a great extent. For example, 70% of South Africans feel homosexuality is ‘wrong’ (Sutherland, 2016) - i.e. immoral, despite the country having broad legal rights and protections for homosexuals. This is a clear example of a situation where the beliefs of the good person and those of the good citizen would diverge, and exploration of similar cases and contradictions reveals the difficulties in being both the good citizen and the good person. Being a good citizen necessitates following the law, even where it may cause harm to ...
An Academic Blog for Watford Grammar School for Boys